Cast & Crew
MyCast&Crew
Login
  • Products

      Accounting and Financial

    • PSL+

      AP payment software that optimizes production accounting.

    • DPO

      Digital solution to manage and optimize purchase orders.​

      Content and Collaboration

    • Studio+

      Digital production document and asset management solution.

    • Final Draft

      Head over to Final Draft to check out the industry standard in screenwriting software.

      Payroll and Human Resources

    • MyCast&Crew

      Help your crews manage their personal and payroll-related materials through one secure hub​​.

    • Start+

      Digital onboarding solution to get your crew started.

    • Hours+

      Digital timecard solution to pay your crew.​​

      Metrics and Insights

    • Reporting+

      Self-service tool that interprets and visualizes your production data.

    • Data+

      An integration to receive your production's raw data.

  • Services
    • Payroll

      Secure, full-service payroll—personalized to your production.​

    • Financial Services

      An overview of your production's health.

    • Residuals

      Fast and accurate payments.​

    • Workers’ Compensation

      Insurance and resources.​

    • Incentives Guide

      A comprehensive breakdown of all available film incentives.

    • Incentives Map

      Compare shoot location options.

    • Resources

      • Open Health

        Healthcare resources designed for non-union employees.​

  • Support and Forms
    • Resource Library

      Tax forms, documents, and more information.​

    • Self-Service Help Center

      Help articles, FAQ, videos, and more.

    • Contact Us

      Emails, phone numbers, and office locations.​

  • Training
    • EDGE

      Register for online training​ and improve your workflow.​

  • About
    • Who We Are
    • Our Companies
      • Backstage

        A one-stop-shop for creators to fully staff their projects.​

      • Canada

        Learn about our solutions in Canada.​

      • CAPS

        Solutions for live events and commercials.​

      • Checks & Balances

        Solutions for live theater payroll.

      • Final Draft

        Solutions for scriptwriting.​

      • Media Services

        Solutions for specialty films and content.​

      • Sargent-Disc

        Solutions for payroll and accounting in the U.K.​

      • The TEAM Companies

        Solutions for live events, advertising, and talent.​

    • Leadership
    • Careers
  • Blog
MyCast&Crew
Login
cc-logo
MyCast&Crew Sign In Contact Us
Menu
Close Menu
  • Open Health
  • Support
  • Forms and Resources
  • Home
  • Industry News
  • Labor & Compliance
  • Industry Insights
  • COVID-19 News
  • News and Culture
  • Spotlight

© 2022 Cast & Crew

  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
< Back to Homepage
BLOG | INDUSTRY INSIGHTS

On the Horizon: Deepfake Part Two

Michael Consiglio
| 02/08/2023
← Back to blog

 What do you believe when you can no longer believe your own eyes?  

There has been a great deal of debate over the past few years about some of the moral implications of using deepfake processes for different ends. Beyond the creative potential of the technology that we discussed in part one of our piece, there are also some severe indications of danger and potential malfeasance. 

Inevitably, this powerful technology raises a host of concerns about privacy and security. There are ways to use it productively, as in recent HBO documentary Welcome to Chechnya, where deepfake “wrappers” were used to protect the identities of LGBTQIA+ activists facing execution in certain regions hostile to their lifestyle. However, the rising chorus of concerns is drowning out most optimistic voices. Many unions have already made it clear that they are firmly against the use of deepfake.6-2 Equity, the U.K. performing arts workers union, already launched the “Stop AI Stealing the Show” campaign, positing that the technology could compromise a performer’s ability to earn a living. If AI allows producers to steal, recreate, and manipulate an individual’s unique assets without paying them (or purposefully underpaying them), then seismic conflicts are certainly inevitable. SAG-AFTRA agrees, and they’ve taken a firm stand on behalf of actors, arguing that the performers must be the ones controlling their own image and how it’s used publicly.   

And while this technology benefits from its democratization, its ubiquity also means that anyone (with any intent) can manipulate a version of reality to their own end. Deepfakes are very easy to create, once the process is understood, so introducing manipulated sounds, images, and videos into already-contentious situations (such as the current political landscape) can be like tossing a match into oil. Ill-intentioned political advocates can theoretically make their opponents do or say anything they like, harming reputations and spreading false information. With that comes the ability for some dishonest people to deny that they ever did or said something that was, in fact, done or said. It’s quite easy to poison the well when most 7-Jan-24-2023-06-18-35-7375-PMpeople trust their eyes and ears. And as these deepfakes become more advanced, it will be increasingly difficult to spot them. Optimistically, knowledge of this fact could add a much-needed boost to media literacy to our society like the way most people had to understand that not every photo they see in a post-Photoshop world is legitimate. However, the potential destruction of trust in media could hurt the effectiveness of legitimate videos and messaging, which would have a devastating effect on things like the world of politics. 


So, how do we counter this trend? Passing laws might be part of the solution. In November of 2020, New York state put a law into effect that bans the use of a person’s likeness and characteristics in digital spaces for 40 years after their death, as such use would most likely lead viewers to assume that it was an authorized reproduction. Texas enacted a similar law in 2019, banning the spread of deepfake videos that were intended to damage political candidates or sway voters within 30 days of an official election. Following Texas’ law, California passed one of its own, expanding the window to 60 days.
 

While the existential sway of the voting class is a major quandary, some concerns are a bit more direct. Take basic criminality, for example. Recently, scammers swindled $35 million from a bank by using deepfake and AI to clone the voice of an executive and forcing a money transfer. And speaking to humanity’s baser instincts, deepfakes in pornography are already causing great strife. Recent reporting from DeepTrace labs showed that 96% of the 14,000 deepfake videos circulating around the internet as of September 2019 were pornographic in nature. These fakeries can cause serious personal, professional, and mental health traumas that can completely upend a person’s world.  

The larger question about deepfake remains: is it ethical to speak for someone else without their consent or knowledge? Should anyone with deepfake technology be allowed to put something into the public square that has the potential to be perceived as authentic when it’s not? From there, the questions fall faster and faster. Does that calculus change if they are a public figure, or must the veil of privacy be drawn out farther? And what of actors or personalities who are no longer with us? Are the dead up for grabs? Can Cary Grant still star in a 2023 summer blockbuster despite having died in 1986? Do Marlon Brando’s career choices no longer matter to a filmmaker in the twenty-first century who wishes to use him to their advantage? Deepfake creators quite literally put words in the mouths of public figures, and surely that must be regulated to some degree. Cineverse, an up-and-coming streaming network, has tossed around the idea of developing specialized channels for performers like Elvis and Bob Ross, showcasing their existing libraries while also creating deepfake content to supplement the archives. To their credit, Cineverse has made a point of conferring with those people who oversee each performer’s copyrights and estates. Of course, some performers are likely to embrace this new concept whole hog. There was some8-Jan-24-2023-06-18-35-3616-PM debate as to whether Bruce Willis licensed his likeness to a Russian mobile service for a series of 2021 commercials (the actor claims he did not). Regardless, the ads were made without the actor ever stepping foot on a set or in a dressing room. While there is currently no regulatory framework in place to allow people to sell their ID rights, performers like Willis can still license them out on an individual basis. This opens a whole new world to performers, whether they’re considering retirement or facing issues that hinder their ability to work, by allowing them to cement their legacies and earn continued income. 

There is also an artistic question to consider: should a piece of work be manipulated by someone other than the artist who created it? Many cineastes were up in arms when George Lucas decided to revisit his classic Star Wars trilogy 25 years ago, arguing that the work was set, and it should not be touched. In that instance, however, it was the film’s creator making the adjustments, so one could argue that it’s his prerogative. Deepfake technology can also be used to colorize classic films that were shot in black and white. Do we need a brightly colored version of Psycho, or should Alfred Hitchcock’s intentions be considered? AI can also be used to generate subtitles and dub international language tracks, but shouldn’t the original performer and filmmakers be involved in that process? But you can’t stop progress, as the saying goes, so it’s possible that AI artists may be as common on the movie sets of the future as VFX artists are today.  

Will the spread of doctored videos lead to the collapse of society as the masses begin to believe everything they see on YouTube? Probably not. Still, this deepfake technology has the potential to alter the very perception of reality in a scalable way. 9-1While it is natural human inclination to worry about a theoretical world where AI starts to create its own videos to manipulate humanity (sounds like a new Terminator film, huh?), there is also a great deal of potential for the emboldening of positive, creative pursuits. There is a long list of technologies that have entered the cinematic conversation only to become commonplace. Don’t forget, it was once unthinkable that actors would speak in a moving picture! In the end, deepfake technology is a tool—a powerful tool—and its legacy will be what we make of it.

Michael Consiglio

With over 15 years of entertainment experience, Michael has written everything from commercial campaigns to comic books. When he's not facedown at his computer, he's most likely cooking, hiking, or slipping subtle 'Indiana Jones' quotes into casual conversation. Michael graduated from the University of Southern California and lives in Los Angeles.

Tags: Industry Insights

We're here to help! Visit our Help Center for answers to your questions.

Visit Help Center →

Share This Post

Related Posts You’ll Love

INDUSTRY INSIGHTS

On the Horizon: Blockchain and Entertainment Part One

  • 7 Minute Read
  • 03/30/2022
INDUSTRY INSIGHTS

On the Horizon: Volumetric Capture and Entertainment Part One

  • 6 Minute Read
  • 07/06/2022
INDUSTRY INSIGHTS

On the Horizon: Artificial Intelligence and Entertainment

  • 7 Minute Read
  • 03/09/2022
illustration-support

Join our mailing list to get the latest insights and news!

  • Products

      Accounting and Financial

    • PSL+
    • DPO
    • Payroll and Human Resources

    • MyCast&Crew
    • Start+
    • Hours+
    • Content and Collaboration

    • Studio+
    • Final Draft
    • Metrics and Insights

    • Reporting+
    • Data+
  • Services

    • Payroll
    • Financial Services
    • Residuals
    • Workers’ Compensation
    • Incentives Guide
    • Incentives Map
  • Support and Forms

    • Resource Library
    • Self-Service Help Center
    • Contact Us
  • Our Companies

    • Canada
    • CAPS
    • Backstage
    • Checks & Balances
    • Final Draft
    • Media Services
    • Sargent-Disc
    • The TEAM Companies
  • Training

    • EDGE
  • About Us

    • Who We Are
    • Leadership
    • Careers
    • Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
  • Resources

    • Open Health
  • Blog

© 2025 Cast & Crew LLC.
All rights reserved.

Cast & Crew and its associated logos are trademarks of Cast & Crew, LLC in the United States and/or other countries. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.

Privacy Policy | Terms of Use

2300 Empire Avenue I Burbank, CA 91504
  • LinkedIn
  • X
  • Facebook